Sunday, 5 April 2015

That Dammed Zambezi - The Cahora Bassa Story

Two thousand five hundred and seventy four kilometres long; flowing past six countries, through 2 hydroelectric dams, under seven bridges and over the magnificent Victoria Falls, the Zambezi River (’the Great River’ in Tsonga) is the longest river flowing east and the fourth longest  river in Africa, its catchment area (1 390 000km2) is half the size of Europe.
View of the gorge downriver from the dam wall
 
The second hydro-electric dam to be built on the Zambezi is at Mozambique’s Cahora Bassa gorge, 125 kilometres away from Tete, the provincial capital.  Even on the sunniest day, the gorge has an imposing manner; the chasm bursts with menace. Enormous rocks and boulders are chaotically piled and scattered as if some almighty infant deity, tired of his building blocks, swept them aside in a childish tantrum.  Millions of tons of water, forced into the narrow crevice created by the frowning and formidable ravine walls, crash and swirl down the impassable rapids.

Where the Work Ends
The local Tsonga named the rapids ‘Kebrabasa – where the work ends’, a faultless description of the impossibility of passage beyond that point.  And Kebrabasa was responsible for the failure of David Livingstone’s 1858 Zambezi expedition - the obstinate doctor finally conceding defeat when his paddle steamer, MaRobert, simply could not get more than three kilometres beyond the gorge entrance.  “God’s Highway”, as Livingstone had described the Zambezi to his financial backers in England, was not to be.  The river defied all attempts to exploit it as access to the continent’s interior, and Livingston referred to it as “that damned Zambezi”.

Apparently a Mr F Monks successfully navigated down the rapids in the early 1880’s, but as no printed report can be found details of his dugout trip remain a mystery.

Local fishing dugout on the dam

Damming the Impassable
With politics easily matching the turbulent river, fast forward to 1956 when the Portuguese government, determined to build a dam, sent a team of hydrologists to survey the region.  The positive report back by the team encouraged the colonial government to steam ahead with its plans.  Environmental impact studies, such as they were, served only to support the government’s objectives, being the expansion of agricultural production, development of mining, forestry promotion, reducing Mozambican dependency on foreign imports and uplifting the living conditions of the local communities.  

A major underlying motive at the time, however, was to encourage an increased population of European settlers who, alongside the physical geographical obstruction of a lake 240kms long and 31kms wide, would act as a barrier to guerrilla forces entering Mozambique from bases in Zambia and Malawi.

The prospect of a massive hydro-electric scheme attracted the South African government into a joint venture with the Portuguese, and construction began on the dam in 1969. It’s hard to comprehend the foolhardy determination to build the biggest hydro-electric dam in Southern Africa, in an inaccessible site on a river famous for unpredictable and frightening floods.  Politically, an international outcry arose, forcing several global companies and banks to withdraw expertise and funding.  Labour, both skilled and unskilled, was in short supply.  Bizarrely, the tragic deaths of seven workers finally convinced local labour that the project was sufficiently dangerous to match the prestigious peril of working on the South African gold mines, and they began signing on to work at Cahora Bassa.

As if determined to shake off the intrusion by man, the gorge delivered a climate of sweltering heat (at times reaching 60° C) with heavy rains in the wet season; combining that with pestilential tropical diseases such as malaria, bilharzia and yellow fever to create indescribable hardship and difficulties for the workers.

Add to this ongoing sabotage - part of the political upheaval signifying the approaching end of colonial Portuguese rule - and you begin to get a picture of complete misery driven by political pride and posturing.

Size Does Count
Costing US$500 million to build, the contract to construct the dam was awarded to Zambeze Consorcio Hidroelectrica Lda (ZAMCO) and included the installation of the electricity generation system and electricity transmission.  The arch dam is 171m high and 303m wide at the crest, with a volume of 510 000 000m3. 

Transport issues arising from its remote location led to the construction in 1973 of the Caetano Bridge (now called Samora Machel Bridge) in Tete, 440 years after the Portuguese first settled in the town.  Completion of the bridge enabled access for the enormous construction machinery required for the building of Cahora Bassa.

Filling of the dam commenced in December 1974 and by April 1975 the dam was virtually complete.  In June of that year Hidroelectrica de Cahora Bassa (HCB) was formed to operate the dam and power station, which has five hydraulic turbines and a total generating capacity of 2075MW.


A White Elephant?
However, Cahora Bassa hadn’t finished its malevolent challenging of the project.  Two days after HCB’s formation, Mozambican independence was declared and the Portuguese left Mozambique forever.  But while Portugal may have handed over the colony, it was adamant the new government take responsibility for the cost of the dam, and insisted that Portugal would retain ownership of Cahora Bassa until that debt was paid off.

The new regime signed a contract with South African electricity giant Eskom to buy the dam’s output, only to have the Mozambique civil war intervene in 1977, putting Cahora Bassa out of service between 1985 and 1997.  The irony of the once Cahora Bassa saboteurs, now the government, fruitlessly trying to secure the power lines and transmitters against rebel guerrillas will not be lost on the reader.

Endless wrangling and negotiation over decades between Mozambique and Portugal culminated in Mozambique obtaining an 85% stake in the scheme for US$ 700m in 2007.  In April 2012, Portugal finally relinquished its interest in the hydro-electric dam - 7.5% sold for US$ 42m to the Mozambican government, and 7.5% passed to Portuguese company Redes Energéticas Nacionais (REN - which operates the Portuguese electricity grid), as part of a future share swap deal.
The wall from the top of the gorge
‘Kebrabasa’
Will the work ever end?  The mighty river is resistant to taming and continues to flood, with politics playing out across the map - oddly reminiscent of the scenario confronting the early European explorers.  Aging facilities have already caused a costly upgrade, and Cahora Bassa reported its first profit only in 2010. 

Things are slowly looking up, however.  In a press release dated 25th November 2014, HCB reported that the 2014 annual power output of the dam had reached 15,892 GWh, an increase of 6.35% on the previous year.

For much of its 39 years, Cahora Bassa has not operated at anything close to capacity; however the Mozambique government is proposing to build a new dam, Mphanda Nkuwa, 60kms downstream, while environmentalists are still unravelling the impact of the existing dam and trying to find solutions.

A new dam may prove to be a wall too many.

Sources:
Zambezi – Journey of a River.  Michael Main 1990 Southern Book Publishers (Pty) Ltd
www.hcb.co.mz
www.iol.co.za (15 April 2012)
A. Isaacman, C. Sneddon Portuguese Colonial Intervention, Regional Conflict and Post-Colonial Amnesia: Cahora Bassa Dam, Mozambique 1965–2002 Cornell Institute for African Development (May 2003)